Almond Butter Substitute

Almond Butter Substitute

Cooking always requires a whole set of ingredients to be available simultaneously. At any time, you will need to stock at least 20 – 30 different ingredients, even for basic home cooking. When it comes to making specific recipes, that list can be extended. Imagine realizing this during the recipe. This situation can occur when you fall short of Almond Butter, an ingredient used in many recipes. It’s a disaster waiting to happen.

Due to its specific taste and texture, you always need only Almond butter in recipes. The richness of taste and flavor it imparts is fantastic. The neutral flavor helps it become a part of many recipes without changing its base taste. Therefore, it’s the number one ingredient if you want to add to cooked or baked food preparations. However, there are times you need to look for a substitute for almond butter, and we are here to help you with precisely that. Not just for spreading it on the toast, you can also substitute for almond butter in baking. There are different scenarios why you need a substitute, and we will explain them below. But there is a way to use each of them, and not all may fit the requirements of a recipe.

Peanut Butter

Peanut butter is one of the most widely accepted and loved products worldwide. There cannot be any other better substitute for almond butter. It is rich, thick and has a slightly sweeter flavor, and is also more neutral. This makes it a naturally preferred substitute and is also significantly cheaper. Thus the best replacement and guess what, you can make it at home too! It’s pretty easy to find at any store and has a long shelf life so that you can stock it for months at a time.

Cashew Butter

While peanut butter is an excellent substitute, it misses almond butter’s rich texture and flavor. If you want to add a rich flavor to the recipe, you can use Cashew butter, which serves the same purpose. It exhibits the same richness and creamy texture as a dried fruit like almonds. Cashews are slightly sweet, and you will need to keep that in mind while using them in place of almond butter. This replacement can be used anywhere, just like almond butter, to spread on toasts, cakes, baked items, etc. While it is recommended that you make it at home, many options are available online.

Pecan Butter

Do you want something even richer and creamier? The answer is Pecan Butter. Pecan closely resembles almond and cashew butter’s taste and flavor profile but is far richer. It also has a distinct nutty flavor and is therefore not neutral. Please keep that in mind when using it in recipes. It’s also quite creamier and easy to spread to be used more efficiently. This product is a little special, and not everyone uses it generally. Therefore it can be pretty challenging to find it in stores. However, you can make your very own homemade one in just a few minutes using the recipes online. It will be healthier and devoid of any harmful preservatives.

Photo by Sara Cervera via Unsplash

Walnut Butter

Walnuts closely resemble pecans, and they have similar characteristics when used as a substitute. While the flavor and the taste are identical to creamy pecans, they can be very nutty. Unlike other options we are considering, this extra nutty flavor leaves a bitter aftertaste which can spoil or change the taste of recipes. So you will have to add a little bit of sweetness like honey or sugar to compensate and neutralize it somewhat. You can do this at home and find it in stores.

walnut butter in shot glasses
Photo by Shreyak Singh via Unsplash

Pistachio Butter

Pistachio butter is another beautiful alternative, the only difference being its appearance. It’s also equally creamy in taste and texture. The Pistachio butter is green in color, limiting its use in some recipes. But, otherwise, it tastes pretty impressive and different from all the other butter we are discussing here.

Hazelnut Butter

Since we have considered all the dried fruits, leaving Hazelnut butter out would be wrong. It’s another nut-based butter that is a good substitute for almond butter. If you mix it with chocolate, you will have a homemade Nutella.

But what if you have an allergy to nuts? Nowadays, people are easily prone to allergies, so not everyone can use nut-based products in their recipes. We have listed some options below that help you substitute with the right product.

Photo by Erol Ahmed via Unsplash

Sunflower Butter

Sometimes people have an allergy to nuts, preventing them from using almond butter and relishing its taste. However, recipes still have to be prepared, and a substitute for almond butter is needed. Sunflower butter is the extract of sunflower seeds. There is no compromise on quality, taste, or health because the sunflower butter is creamy and exhibits the same neutral flavor as Almond butter. Therefore its become a widely accepted butter for people with a nut allergy. Also, it’s readily available at all grocery stores, and it’s almost always in stock. You will also find a lot of information online about preparing it at home.

sunflower butter stacked on a shelf
Photo by Aaron Doucett via Unsplash

Pumpkin Seed Butter

Pumpkin seeds butter is also known as pepitas. This butter is just like Sunflower seeds but is creamy and green like pistachios butter.

Read more:

pumpkin seeds
Photo by Eva Elijas via Pexels

Final Words

That’s it. These are all the substitutes available for use. Each of the replacements we have considered has its specific taste and flavor profile. You may need to check each one before understanding what works for you and what does not. So it is up to individual preferences, and you can always make a small amount at home to check. I hope the information in the article has been helpful.

Jillian Noon

Hi, I am Jillian Noon, the owner of this beautiful cooking blog. I create this blog to share my passion for cooking and other kitchen & food tips. I hope you will enjoy it!

Recent Posts